RU EN

Friendly Turkish › Grammar by level › Must, have to, should have — and must have

Must, have to, should have — and must have

Gereklilik kipi ve hikâyesi, -⁠mak zorunda, tahmin: -⁠mış olmalı

Advice, a rule that leaves you no choice, a reproach for what wasn’t done, even a guess: Turkish has a form for each. And one line never blurs, the one between “mustn’t” and “don’t have to”.

The full story is in:Course 2, Lesson 1Course 2, Lesson 2Course 2, Lesson 19

1The one-⁠minute version

Ask who’s deciding. You think it’s the right thing: -⁠malı. There’s no choice — a rule, the boss, the way things went: zorunda. It should have been done, and wasn’t: -⁠malıydı. And when “must” is no duty at all but a guess about what’s already happened: -⁠mış olmalı.

The formula

must -⁠mAlIhave to -⁠mAk zorunda
yesstem + -⁠mAlI + whogelmeliyimstem + -⁠mAk zorunda + whogelmek zorundayım
notstem + -⁠mA + -⁠mAlI + whogelmemeliyimstem + -⁠mAk zorunda değil + whogelmek zorunda değilim
questionstem + -⁠mAlI, then mI + whogelmeli miyim?
looking backstem + -⁠mAlI + -⁠(y)dI + whogelmeliydimstem + -⁠mAk zorunda kal- + -⁠dI + whogelmek zorunda kaldım
a guess about the paststem + -⁠mIş + olmalı + whogelmiş olmalı

After -⁠mAlI and zorunda, the “who” is Course 1 Lesson 1’s ending, as in öğretmenim; before the ending’s vowel a y steps in, as in hastayım; “they” in a question is gelmeliler mi? (the table below). After -⁠(y)dI it’s the past endings: -⁠m, -⁠n, -⁠k, -⁠nIz, -⁠lAr. In a guess the “who” goes on olmalı and the “not” on the verb: gelmemiş olmalı. A guess about now is most often olmalı after a word: evde olmalı. zorunda’s question, and -⁠malıydı’s “not” and question, are in “How it works”.

Lines to remember

— Başım çok ağrıyor. — Biraz yatmalısın.— I’ve got a bad headache. — You should lie down for a bit.
Ayakkabılarımı çıkarmalı mıyım?Should I take my shoes off?
Gitmemelisin. — Gitmek zorunda değilsin.You mustn’t go. — You don’t have to go.
Biletleri önceden almalıydık.We should have bought the tickets in advance.
Saat on bir oldu. Film bitmiş olmalı.It’s gone eleven. The film must have finished.

Clue words

Advice, duty: -⁠malı

  • mutlaka“definitely”; in a guess, “surely”: about the past -⁠mış olmalı, about now olmalı

No choice: zorunda

  • kural“a rule”: no choice because of it, zorunda; the rule itself, on paper or a sign, -⁠malı, -⁠malıdır

About the past: it wasn’t done, -⁠malıydı; there was no choice, zorundaydı or zorunda kaldı; a guess, -⁠mış olmalı

  • dün
  • geçen hafta

Watch out

Not like thisLike thisWhy
Gelmeliydi.Gelmiş olmalı.You meant “he must have come”, a guess. English has no past of “must”, so a guess about the past is “must have” + the verb; but -⁠malıydı is “should have”: gelmeliydi is “he should have come”. The guess puts -⁠mış on the verb and olmalı after it.

2At a glance

Must -⁠malı/-⁠meli

When
you yourself think it’s right: advice, duty, a rule
Example
Bu kitabı mutlaka okumalısın — “you really must read this book”
Vowel
-⁠malı after a, ı, o, u; -⁠meli after e, i, ö, ü
Not
okumamalısın — “you mustn’t read it”, never “you don’t have to”
Looking back
okumalıydın — “you should have read it”: the third card
Also
on signs, -⁠malıdır; people in general, insan

Have to -⁠mak zorunda

When
there’s no choice: a rule, the boss, the way things went
Example
Her gün baret takmak zorundayız — “we have to wear hard hats every day”
Vowel
-⁠mak or -⁠mek; zorunda’s vowels never change
Not
takmak zorunda değiliz — “we don’t have to”: we can if we like
Looking back
zorundaydık — that was the rule; zorunda kaldık — that’s how it turned out
Also
mecbur, the same, with the action in -⁠(y)A: gitmeye mecburum

Should have -⁠malıydı

When
it should have been done, and wasn’t: regret, or reproach
Example
Daha erken çıkmalıydık — “we should have left earlier”
Vowel
-⁠malıydı after a, ı, o, u; -⁠meliydi after e, i, ö, ü
Not
below, in “How it works”
Looking back
this is -⁠malı’s past: -⁠(y)dı, as in hastaydım
Also
zorunda’s past is another thing: “had to”, the second card

Must have done -⁠mış olmalı

When
no duty at all: a guess about what’s already happened, from the clues or just by reasoning
Example
Komşular tatilden dönmüş olmalı — “the neighbours must be back from holiday”
Vowel
-⁠mış has four: -⁠mış, -⁠miş, -⁠muş, -⁠müş; olmalı’s vowels never change
Not
dönmemiş olmalı — “they can’t be back”: the “not” goes on the verb
Looking back
it’s a guess about the past already; about now, most often olmalı after a word: evde olmalı
Also
the “who” goes on olmalı: yorulmuş olmalısın
who-⁠malımustmiquestion-⁠malıydıshould haveolmalımust have
benIgelmeliyimgelmeli miyim?gelmeliydimgelmiş olmalıyım
senyougelmelisingelmeli misin?gelmeliydingelmiş olmalısın
ohe, shegelmeligelmeli mi?gelmeliydigelmiş olmalı
bizwegelmeliyizgelmeli miyiz?gelmeliydikgelmiş olmalıyız
sizyou (pl.)gelmelisinizgelmeli misiniz?gelmeliydinizgelmiş olmalısınız
onlartheygelmelilergelmeliler mi?gelmeliydilergelmiş olmalılar

3The key points

4How it works

On signs, in rules and instructions, the third person takes -⁠dır: -⁠malıdır. And to talk about people in general, Turkish uses insan, “a person”:

İnsan dürüst olmalı.— You should be honest.

There’s a negative question too — gelmemeli miyim, “shouldn’t I come, then?” — but it’s rare and has a note of reproach.

gitmek zorunda is literally “in the compulsion of going”, and the “who” follows it as it follows any noun. In zorunda kaldım, kalmak means “to end up”: that’s how things turned out.

mecbur means what zorunda does, but the action before it goes into the dative: Gitmeye mecburum, “I’m obliged to go”. It makes a good short answer: Mecbur değilsin, “you don’t have to”, and mecburen, “because I have to, nothing for it”. With kalmak, as with zorunda: mecbur kaldım, “I had no choice”. Laws and contracts write -⁠mak mecburiyetindedir: recognise it; don’t say it over tea:

Kiracılar kirayı her ayın beşine kadar ödemek mecburiyetindedir.— Tenants are required to pay the rent by the fifth of each month.

zorunda takes its question like any word: mI apart, the “who” on it: gelmek zorunda mıyım?. -⁠malıydı’s “not” sits where -⁠malı’s does, straight after the stem: gelmemeliydim, “I shouldn’t have come”. In the question, -⁠(y)dı and the “who” move onto mI, as in hasta mıydın?: gelmeli miydim?, “should I have come?”

Three “no”s on one form, and each says something else:

Bu formu doldurmamalısın.— You mustn’t fill in this form (it isn’t yours).
Bu formu doldurmana gerek yok.— There’s no need for you to fill in this form (I’ve done it).
Bu formu doldurmak zorunda değilsin.— You don’t have to fill in this form (do it if you like).

A guess about the past takes two words. The verb gets -⁠mış, with its four vowels, and olmalı follows, its vowels never changing: gelmiş olmalı, bitmiş olmalı, unutmuş olmalı, görmüş olmalı. It’s what you say about something you didn’t see but worked out:

Telefonu kapalı. Uçağa binmiş olmalı.— His phone’s off. He must have got on the plane.

The “who” goes on olmalı, with -⁠malı’s own endings, and the “not” on the verb, before -⁠mış:

Yolu kaybetmiş olmalıyız.— We must have lost our way.
Mesajımı görmemiş olmalı, hâlâ cevap yok.— He can’t have seen my message: there’s still no reply.

To ask for someone’s guess, a plain -⁠mış mı? will do:

Film bitmiş mi?— Do you think the film’s over?

Plain -⁠mış can guess from the traces too. With a trace in front of you, people say it either way, Gece yağmur yağmış or Gece yağmur yağmış olmalı, “it must have rained in the night”. With no trace, when you’re simply reasoning — from the clock, from habit — -⁠mış olmalı is what most people choose:

Babam her gün altıda işten çıkar. Saat yedi oldu: Eve gelmiş olmalı.— Dad leaves work at six every day. It’s gone seven: he must be home by now.

And don’t mix the guess up with -⁠malıydı — here they are on one stem:

Gelmeliydi. — Gelmiş olmalı.— He should have come (and didn’t). — He must have come.

5In real life

asking what to doBugün ilk günüm. Ne yapmalıyım?It’s my first day today. What should I do?
a doctor’s adviceBu ilacı yemekten sonra almalısınız.You should take this medicine after meals.
a written ruleAdaylar sınava kimlik kartıyla gelmelidir.Candidates must bring an ID card to the exam.
no choiceAsansör bozuk, beşinci kata merdivenle çıkmak zorundayız.The lift’s broken, so we have to take the stairs to the fifth floor.
how it turned outToplantı çok uzadı, son vapuru kaçırdım. Arkadaşımda kalmak zorunda kaldım.The meeting ran on and on, and I missed the last ferry. I ended up staying at a friend’s.
in short— Pazar günü de mi çalışıyorsun? — Ne yapayım, mecburum.— You’re working on Sunday too? — What can I do? I have to.
a guess about yourselfAnahtarlarım yok. Arabada unutmuş olmalıyım.My keys aren’t here. I must have left them in the car.

6Where it’s easy to slip

Not like thisLike thisWhy
gelmelimiyim?gelmeli miyim?mi is written apart, and the “who” goes on it.
gelmeliyimdigelmeliydimFirst -⁠(y)dı, then the “who”, as in hastaydım.
gelmeye zorundayımgelmek zorundayımzorunda takes a bare -⁠mak; the dative is mecbur’s.
unutmuşum olmalıunutmuş olmalıyımIn a guess, the “who” goes on olmalı.

7Say it yourself

No options here: say it or write it in Turkish yourself, and only then open the answer. Got it wrong? That’s the miss that makes it stick.

you’re the doctor: tell a patient, politely, that they mustn’t eat sweet things
ask at a new office whether you have to wear your pass all day
text why you’re late: you ended up waiting half an hour for the bus
you’re lost: you should have brought a map
the stairwell smells of coffee: your neighbour must be up already
your friend’s eyes are red: tell him he must have been up all night

8Check yourself

Four questions, each with two or three rules at once: which form, where the “not” and the “who” go, which case. Every wrong answer slips on exactly one.

1You’ve hurt a friend with a sharp remark. Say: “I shouldn’t have said that.”

2Your brother isn’t picking up. “He must have left his phone at home.”

Kardeşim açmıyor. Telefonunu evde ?

3Ask at the hotel desk: “Do we have to show our passports?”

4There were no buses at midnight, so we had no choice but to take a taxi.

Gece yarısı otobüs yoktu, taksiye ?

A text with gaps

A message in the morning. Each gap is one form, and what’s round it decides which.

Nehir writes to Arda, her flatmate

Arda, günaydın!

Mutfakta yerler ıslak, makinenin altında su var.

5Çamaşır makinesi gece ?.

Ustayı aradım, bugün saat üçte gelecek. Ben üçte toplantıdayım.

6Biri ona kapıyı ?.

Sen evde olabilir misin?

7Bir de makineyi ?: Tehlikeli olabilir.

Dün akşam makineden garip sesler geldi.

8Ustayı dün ?!

Görüşürüz, Nehir